There’s been a real quandary over the past few months here at Dying Art Media. Granted, it’s a bit of a first-world problem, but it’s something we try to wrestle with as we maintain an objective view on things we’re reviewing. And it’s hard. Are the modern re-makes of our favourite games good, because they’re good games, and excellent remakes. Or are they good because of how powerful nostalgia is? Objectivity is tricky sometimes.
When we revisit video games that captured our imaginations decades ago, we aren’t just evaluating frame rates, polygons, and design philosophies. We are evaluating ghosts. For many of us who first experienced the landmark shift into three dimensions at twelve years old—losing countless hours to cartridges like The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time after cutting our teeth on handheld adventures like Link’s Awakening. Memory is a generous editor. It gently sands down frustrating inventory management, repetitive corridor layouts, and archaic camera mechanics, leaving behind only the pure, golden emotional resonance of a mind blown in our formative years.
This year’s major releases of the Ocarina of Time remake and Halo: Campaign Evolved force a fascinating collision between memory and reality. They bring our childhood touchstones roaring back into the modern era with pristine fidelity, thrusting us straight into a timeless debate: are these games genuinely brilliant classics, or are our rose-tinted glasses simply hiding the cracks? Are we able to hold true objectivity?

The Illusion of the Past
The central quandary of any high-profile remake is a tightrope walk between reverence and critique. Memory tells us these games were flawless masterpieces, but modern design standards demand rigorous accountability. When a studio faithfully rebuilds these pillars for contemporary hardware, a distinct paradox emerges immediately.
If a remake stays entirely faithful to the source material, critics are quick to point out dated structural choices, arguing that the underlying design has aged poorly. Yet, if the developers dare to change too much, tweaking narrative beats, restructuring levels, or altering core mechanics. The purists rise up, accusing the studio of desecrating sacred ground. Examining how Ocarina of Time and Halo: Campaign Evolved handle this scrutiny reveals a lot about what makes a game truly endure.
This is how we maintain objectivity, by looking at things through a specific lens. Not just nostalgia, but not just “how did they remake my game”. It’s a combination of that and the usual perspectives of fun, engagement etc.

Ocarina of Time
In the case of Ocarina, the overwhelming critical and player consensus points firmly toward a game that is an actual, undeniable classic rather than a mere nostalgia trip. The core structural DNA of Ocarina of Time invented a grammar of 3D space, combat locking, and environmental puzzle-solving that subsequent generations have iterated upon rather than fundamentally reinvented.
Temples like the Forest and Spirit dungeons rely on spatial geometry and multi-layered progression that still function today as absolute masterclasses in level design. Objectivity is easy here.
Even when stripped of its 1998 awe-factor, the thematic weight of transitioning from child Link to adult Link anchors the entire journey with remarkable narrative gravity. Nintendo didn’t need to rewrite the underlying game; by smoothing out the friction points and modernising responsiveness, the architecture of Hyrule proved its skeleton was built to last. It succeeds as both a phenomenal game and a faithful remake.
Without taking the time to really examine this, though, we’ve had to fall-back on the core premise for all of our reviews. “Is this fun?” and it’s an undeniable yes. Regardless of nostalgia or standard of remake. Is it an enjoyable experience from top to bottom? Yes.

Halo: Campaign Evolved: The Sandbox Test and Modern Friction
Halo: Campaign Evolved presents a thornier, more polarised case study. While lauded for wrapping its iconic cooperative loops in breathtaking modern visuals, it also reignites fierce discussions about where original production shortcuts meet modern expectations.
The core “thirty seconds of fun” sandbox loop (where grenade physics, recharging shields, and aggressive enemy AI constantly interact) remains brilliantly engaging. The fundamental gun-play feels incredible because Bungie’s player-to-enemy combat dynamics were leagues ahead of their time in 2001.
However, absolute objectivity forces us to reckon with the game’s infamous structural fatigue, particularly the repetitive copy-pasted environments of its second half, such as The Library or the endless corridor backtracking.
When rendered with hyper-realistic fidelity, a tedious room layout cannot hide behind low-polygon charm. It demands to be judged by current design standards.
Furthermore, narrative tweaks and new mission additions invite immediate community friction, proving how difficult it is to touch a beloved relic without sparking a debate over preservation versus alteration.
Granted, we actually loved this remake, and we’re looking forward to another run-through, especially with Firefight mode coming to it, too. And, we were raised on this as the high standard for shooters, so it’s far less grating to older heads, in our opinion. And that’s where nostalgia/experience comes into play.
Able to look past what some now see as pacing issues in a game that rightfully deserves “Masterpiece” status. Are we letting nostalgia rule our perspective a little too much?

The Museum Versus the Living Stage
When we strip away the marketing hype and the comforting warmth of nostalgia, the question of whether true game preservation requires faithful remakes or original hardware forces us to confront a fundamental identity crisis: are video games historical artifacts to be preserved under glass, or are they living scores meant to be played?
Original hardware and source code preservation offer the unvarnished truth. They give us the friction, the hardware limitations, the quirks, and the authentic context of the era. To the purist archivist, a remake is always an interpretation, an adaptation that risks obscuring the historical reality of what creators achieved with primitive tools.
Yet, as landmark releases like Ocarina of Time and Halo: Campaign Evolved demonstrate, video games are uniquely interactive. Unlike a film on celluloid or a painting in a gallery, a game remains completely inert until a human hand breathes life into its code.
True game preservation is not merely about keeping dead hardware functional in a dusty closet; it is about keeping cultural memory accessible and emotionally resonant for contemporary audiences. Original hardware degrades, cathode-ray tube televisions vanish, and archaic control schemes can act as brick walls rather than badges of honour. A masterfully executed faithful remake acts as a bridge, stripping away unintended technical frustrations so that the original design intent can finally shine through clearly.
Ultimately, hardware preservation protects the past, but faithful remakes preserve the experience. The rose-tinted glasses don’t invent the beauty. They simply help us see what was brilliantly engineered into the foundation all along.

Staying objective
All of this is to say that whilst we’re heavily impacted by our nostalgia and longing for those halcyon days where we were unburdened by the wider world and life in general. These remakes are absolutely an escape to a simpler time in many ways. But, we’re mindful enough to look at them with a different perspective as well and ask those same simple questions we ask in every review.
Is it fun? Is it engaging? Are we enjoying it?
When all the boxes are ticked, we can rest easy knowing it isn’t just nostalgia at play. But we can continue to be critical of other elements, especially that of change and “enhancement”.
We like to think that the fact that we’re even wrestling with this subject is enough to show just how much we care about the opinion we put to page. Objectivity can be hard, but it’s so important in a world of paid-for content and influencers. Our independence and being beholden to nobody but ourselves, means we can be honest.
We can be wrong, or disagreed with, for sure. But, we remain objective and always working out what makes us feel the way we feel about things.
